Dual citizenship, expired SA passport, can I enter on UK passport



  • edited 12:21PM
    Hi, I would not bother contacting them via telephone. If I were her, I would enter and leave as a British tourist on the UK passport, then: either apply for a renewed passport at her leisure when she gets back, or apply here and have it couriered her when its ready (in about 6 weeks provided she has the new ID and her fingerprints are on the database).
  • edited 12:21PM
    Danb - IMHO, based on family members who have done this, the London office can process you application right there, and have your passport returned to you in about 8 weeks or even less. It should entail one visit only, and you can get the passport couriered up to Manchester.
  • edited 12:21PM
    We are now living in the UK and I applied for a renewal on my daughters SA passport on the 18th January 2011. I was told at the time (via the website) that this application can take up to 4 months. It is now May (4 months later) and have done a check to see the status as we are due for travel in November / December. The status website says that no application has been sent. I have sent an email to the SA consulate in London but had no response as yet. What is the best way of getting a response regarding the whereabout of the application as it contains personal information. It was posted to the London office via registered royal mail. Please assist with contact details
  • edited 12:21PM
    Hi all,

    My tale is one of caution to you all .... I have now lost my South African citizenship as I applied for my British Passport (through registration as my mother is British). The very rude and condescending lady at Home Affairs in London quite gleefully took both my outdated passport and temporary passport and cut the corners in front of me, then handed me a letter stating that I had "willingly" applied for another citizenship without prior request from South Africa and in doing so had contravened act so and so and so .....

    Never mind the fact that I argued the Citizenship Amendement Act of 15 September 2004, and subsequent comments from Home Office stating that it was against human rights to disallow residents dual nationality, and that letters of approval were no longer needed.

    She refused to budge. I have made contact with a fellow South African who had the same lady and he took his case to 702 radio and all in all the feedback from Home Office was that he was lying and they can change the laws whenever they want to, end of. Never mind the fact that both him and I were dealing with Mr Johannes Tiba, the past head of Immigrations and Civil Services! "That doesn't matter what he said" I was told.

    So, please, before you apply for UK Citizenship or any other citizenship go in person to the Home Office and take all your papers with you, and do it there and then. Believe you me, both my Father and I have had to go there ourselves instead of waiting for email, phone or post. They actually lost my Fathers and he had to drive all the way down from Leeds to come and demand it from them.

    Do not apply for any citizenship until you have acknowledgement from South African Home Office that you can do this.

    Ironically, as we are born in SA, even if we lose our citizenship, we are still entitled to go back and live there and work. After 5 years we can then request for SA citizenship again.

    It's all madness!
  • edited 12:21PM
    Hi Rosy, I am in the same boat, do you know if there's been any movement on this? The SAHC web site (as far as I recall) had the same text as Page 1 of this post, namely that "inter alia" the system of letters for dual nationals doesn't apply - on that basis I didn't/couldn't apply for retention.

    Is it worth me writing to the Commissioner or my parents' MP back in RSA?

  • edited 12:21PM
    hey there..im not sure if this question has been asked but im going to ask anyway :]..
    i have {SA}+{UK} passport
    {born in UK..but living in SA}
    moving back to the UK in 2 weeks but just discovered my SA passport is expired.. can i leave SA with my UK passport? considering i was born in England....if not.... could i leave with a temp SA passport??
  • edited 12:21PM
    Please can someone assist with some advice URGENTLY!
    My husband is an SA citizen, born in SA and living in SA. As his parents are Scottish and live in Scotland, he has a British passport. His mom is very ill and he has to go over there urgently and is travelling tomorrow.
    Problem is, when he checked his docs, SA passport expires in October. British Passport is new and valid. I believe you need at least 6 Months before expiry in order to travel on an SA passport. Does he go out and come back on the British passport and show the expiring SA passport? Could this prove to be a problem?
    Thanks very much!
  • edited 12:21PM
    @Clare - it seems simple enough: he exits and re-enters SA on his SA passport, and enters and leaves UK on his UK passport. This is the process followed by thousands of dual passport holders every month.
  • edited 12:21PM
    Thanks DavidF. The probelm is that his SA passport expires in October. Will that not be a problem?
  • edited 12:21PM
    The expiry rule only applies to foreign countries you are entering. SA immigration have no reason to prevent him exiting or entering on a valid SA passport - even if it expires in a month or so.
  • edited 12:21PM
    That makes sense! Thanks very much for your time. Much relief :-)
  • edited 12:21PM
    DavidF , your comments above have been most helpful as I am awaiting my temp SA passport to be issued as it took 3 months for the Home Office to confirm in writing that I am a SA Citizen that they have agreed to issue it to me in in the meantime as I am travelling to SA in the next couple of weeks. I wasn't a 100% sure whether it was legal for me to travel on 2 passports, I have a British passport by birth and SA from citizenship but reading your comments you said that loads of people leave and enter Britain on their British and enter and leave SA on their SA one, so pleased to hear that! If anyone requires info from the SA High Commission in London I have been dealing directly Mrs Menezes and found her to be extremely helpful.
  • edited 12:21PM
    My son was born in Cape Town in 1992. I am British born (with British and SA Passports) and his father is Australian born (with Australian and SA Passports). My son has British and Australia Passports and when we left SA in 1997 to move to Scotland, I got a letter from the Home Office giving "permission to utilise a foreign passport". My son has never had a SA passport. He does have an ID no. though on his birth certificate.

    He now wants to visit his dad in Cape Town on an open ticket - he will be travelling on his British passport and I wanted to know if he will need a visa as he might stay more than 90 days. I still have the letter from Home Office, but its from 1997.
  • edited 12:21PM
    Hi, seems like there is a lot of people not happy with the SA embassy in London. I rung today and was given a very rude answer by a lady, they are not very helpful. My husband and I both have dual passports, have lived in the Uk for the past 12 years, our son was born here and only has a British Passport. Both our SA passports have expired. We own property here and never ever plan on living in SA again. Now we have a trip booked for DEC this year to SA for 2 weeks and what do we do? Can they refuse you entry? What is this talk about a fine? Surely they cannot do that?
    It takes more than 3 months to denounce your SA citizenship. What do we do? Take the chance and just enter on our British?
    HELP please
  • edited 12:21PM
    Hi Danny am in the same situation still searching for answers as well. If you do get an answer please e-mail me and will do likewise. Ta
    . mabenaw@yahoo.com
  • edited 12:21PM
    @Danny - why don't you just enter on your British passports as UK citizens? They won't know or care that you have SA passports.
  • edited 12:21PM
    Danny & gp4sure,
    I am in same situation - travelling to SA soon with a 'dormant' SA citizenship and expired passport. The SA High Commission here in Australia indicates that it can take up to 9 months to denounce your SA citizenship. However, they issue a letter that allows you to enter SA on your foreign (in my case Aussie) passport.
    I can only assume it should work the same from anywhere (whether it does may be another matter ;) I've attached the link so you can see for yourself.
    Hope it helps
  • edited 12:21PM
    My son was born in South Africa but we live in the UK. He has a UK passport but I never got a SA passport for him. His UK passport says he's born in Cape Town. He is only going to SA for 3 months so won't need a visa. He left UK recently and arrived in SA on his British passport - got through Customs no problem (the Customs Official even mentioned that he could see he was born in SA and was he there to work or holiday - my son stated holiday and Customs Official told him to enjoy his stay). I was so worried after reading stories of not being allowed to travel to SA on a foreign passport if you're South African, but my son had no problems.
  • edited 12:21PM
    My daughter was born in Cape Town in 1986 to British Citizens - we moved back to UK in 1989. She has never had an S.A. Passport just a British one - we visited S.A. with her in 1998 and there was no problem. Now she is applying for a visa for Australia and they want to know if she has dual citizenship - Does she automatically have this with SA because she was born there?
  • edited 12:21PM
    From peoples personal experience, how long is a SA passport renewal typically taking at the moment when applied for at the High Commission in London...? I know that on their website they indicate 4 months, although I've heard that it sometimes only takes a few weeks... Thanks...
  • edited 12:21PM
    hi all
    here is my problem.im a south african and ive got residance in the uk.i want to go to spain to go and visit my girlfriend.
    i have 3months left on my pasport and im busy applyin for a renewal of my pasport.do i still need a visa to go to spain even if im a resadant of the uk??
    please give me advise because i want to go to spain in 5 weeks time!!!
    please please help
  • edited 12:21PM
    Hi Haasdaas

    This is a very tricky situation -- is your girlfriend an EEA national?

    You DON'T require a visa if you have a UK residency permit, AND if you are travelling to Spain to join an EEA national.

    The issue of your passport only have three months left before it expires also complicates matters.

    I think your best course of action is to get hold of your nearest Spanish embassy in the UK, and CAREFULLY explain your situation to them, and act on their advice.
  • edited 12:21PM
    Hi My sister is due to travel to SA on the 7 November 2011, she applied for her SA passport to be renewed 5 months ago, checked up with them regularly and was told that it was being processed. She phoned again on Frit 7 Oct, to be told they (SA Consulate) have now lost some of her documents, but acknowledge that they did receive them.They can issue her with a travel doc , so that she can come to Sa to visit our mom, who is ill., but cannot explain how she can leave SA to return to the UK. She has permanent residency in the Uk.
    Will she be able to get back into the UK on a temporay SA passport
  • edited 12:21PM
    Hello Janette

    Wow, what a horrible situation for your sister to find herself in...

    Unfortunately, she WILL NOT be allowed to enter the UK on a temporary South African passport. This rule was brought into effect earlier this year for 'security reasons'.

    I think her best bet would be to contact the South African embassy in London, explain her situation, and see what they advise.

    Otherwise, the best I can think of would be to get in touch with the Department of Home Affairs back in South Africa, and see if they can prepare a passport for her here, so she can pick it up and use it for travelling back to the UK. Of course, the process would have to be heavily expedited, but -- again, if she explains the awkward situation she has been landed in -- perhaps a plan can be made.

    Sorry we can't be of more help. Good luck, and please keep us updated on your sister's progress.
  • edited 12:21PM
    Dual citizenship issues clarified

    15 November 2004

    The government has appealed to South Africans with dual citizenship to use their South African passports when leaving or returning to the country.

    According to the South African Citizenship Amendment Act of 2004, that came into effect on 15 September, it is now an offence for locals with dual citizenship to use their foreign passports to leave or gain entry to the country.

    It is also an offence for a citizen, while in South Africa, to use his or her foreign citizenship to gain advantage or avoid a responsibility or duty, says the Department of Home Affairs.

    However, the new Act allows South Africans with dual nationality to freely use their foreign passports outside South Africa.

    A provision of the South African Citizenship Act of 1995, allowing the minister of home affairs to deprive a citizen of his or her citizenship for having used the citizenship of a foreign country, has been repealed.

    As a result, the need for exemptions or letters of permission from the minister to make use of a foreign passport has now been terminated.

    "The issue of deprivation of citizenship was inconsistent with the Constitutional right to citizenship", said Home Affairs spokesperson Nkosana Sibuyi.

    "Accordingly, we would like to advise all South Africans who have dual citizenship and do not have South African passports to apply for their South African passports at the earliest opportunity."

    The department said it was mindful that many affected South Africans might not yet be aware of the amendments and their implications.

    "We have therefore decided that affected South Africans departing or arriving through our ports of entry, attempting to use a foreign passport, will be issued with a warning giving them three months to obtain a South African passport", Sibuyi said.

    He added that authorities would not, in the meantime, prevent anyone from leaving or entering the country, provided they had applied for the relevant document.

    Source: BuaNews
  • edited 12:21PM
    I live in California and became a US citizen last year (after getting the permission letter from the consulate in LA). Got my US passport in 3 biz days plus they fedexed it to me! Of course my SA passport has expired and as SA does not allow renewals and takes 6 months to issue a new passport I will not be able to enter on it. My travel agent's advice - that I apply before I leave and have proof of application on hand at entry supports what the last commentator said. So I will be entering on my US and if asked, provide proof of application for SA passport. Plus I plan on having the permission letter on hand as well.
  • edited 12:21PM
    Hi guys,

    I have a question will I be in trouble with UK Immigration if I exit the UK using my British Passport, but using my SA passport to enter and exit South Africa, and then enter the UK with my Brisith passport?

    Will UK Immigration querry where have I travelled? If I told them I was in South Africa, will they ask why didn't I use my British passport to enter SA as there were be no stamps? I hope not to get into trouble with UK Borders with my British passport.

    Many thanks.
  • edited 12:21PM
    Urgent: how can I get the letter of retention, after the 3 month window has expired? I did not know about this letter in 1999 when I obtained my UK passport, now I'm in a difficult position if I want to retain my SA citizenship!
  • edited 12:21PM
    Hi All

    I hold dual nationality (British and South African Passports). I am due to travel back to South Africa, in exactly 2 weeks time and have just noticed that my SA passport expired in June. I have read the above comments and am now very worried that i could get refused entry or fined if i try to enter SA on my British Passport.
    I have a SA ID book, will they allow me entry, on the promise of renewing my SA passport whilst there, with my expired SA passport and ID book or should i risk entering on my British Passport. Also, if i enter on my British Passport, will i have to leave on my British passport as i believe this is when others have been questioned.

    Please reply asap, thank you in anticipation. Ryan
  • edited 12:21PM
    I have dual (UK&SA) and recently went to Ireland to renew my SA passport - it was cheaper to fly there from Manchester than getting a train to London!! I explained that I needed to go back to SA early next year and was told by them I should def not try enter SA on my UK passport! She said if I still didn't have my passport back within a few weeks of the time I have to travel, I should apply for a temporary passport which takes up to 14 days to come through

    They were VERY helpful, checked my forms and toook my finger prints. The best thing is they even answer the phone and you don't have to ring a premium rate number!! If you having any doubts or problems, I can fully recommend ringing them or if you can get a cheap flight to dublin, they do a walk in service (no appointment necessary) 9am - 12midday (double check times and days before you go)

    Ireland - South African Embassy
    Alexandra House
    2nd Floor
    Earlsfort Centre
    Earlsfort Terrace
    Dublin 2

    Tel: + 353 1 661 5553
    Fax: + 353 1 661 5590
    Fax: + 353 1 661 5582 (Consular)

    Good Luck!
  • edited 12:21PM
    Oh and for Bokkie - I always leave and enter UK on my British passport and enter/leave SA on my SA passport. It avoids a ton of questions and problems especially when you coming back into the UK.
  • edited 12:21PM
    CJS has the key, if you need to travel to SA and don't have an SA passport, just apply for a temporary SA passport, which is good for entering SA (and remaining in compliance with the citizenship act), but really useless for anything else. It is relatively quick to get at most consulates. Once you arrive in SA, then just apply for your SA passport at any department of home affairs. Home Affairs in SA have really jacked up their system, and produce SA passports in under 2 weeks now, even in non-major centers like Port Elizabeth.

    Those of you that have not applied for permission to have dual citizenship prior to being naturalized as a foreign national should be aware that the consquence of not doing this means loss off your SA citizenship, however, you retain permanent residence of SA, ie., you have the right to live and work in SA - in fact most of the rights of citizenship - with the exception that you cannot vote and don't have the right to a SA passport. Thus you would be able to use your foreign passport to enter SA and the fact that you have a national ID would mean you are able to remain indefinitly. I don't know how this works in practise at the airport, but that's what the act says :-)
  • edited 12:21PM
    I have just returned from London from the South African High Commission Office. Had a very helpful lady but a nightmare of form filling etc. If you were BORN in South Africa regardless of parentage etc.etc. if you wish to travel to South Africa you MUST have a South African passport. Check, for example, your British passport (I am a British citizen) and you will see place of birth e.g.Cape Town - that is what officials will be looking for and that will determine which passport you are able to enter SA on. You can no longer therefore renounce your South African citizenship or lose it because you fell under the old rules. In order to get a SA passport you have to be reinstated, if like me you still hold an old ID book , you have to get a new one. Because I need to travel to South Africa fairly soon because of family illness I have applied for a temporary passport - if you go in person it could take as little as 5 working days - and at the same time for a full passport - takes 4 months. I had to pay for reinstatement, new ID book, temporary passport and full passport - all totalling £97.00 or about R1 100. I had to take 2 copies of old ID book, SA passport which expired in early 1995, British passport, Certificate of naturalisation, marriage certificate and various forms. All these were certified at the High Commission Office and fingerprints were taken there. I wear glasses and although I checked that I could keep them on as they did not cover my eyes I had to run to Charing Cross station and have new ones taken in case they were rejected because of eye recogniton - so my advice DO NOT WEAR YOUR GLASSES - I have spent a fortune on ugly photos!!! If you do not want to go and pick up your passport you need a prepaid recorded?registered self addressed envelope as well - I only had one with first class stamp and as this was not acceptable will go up again. With trainfare from East Sussex for my husband and I plus sanwiches and coffee (no food or drink allowed while waiting at the consulate) it was a very expensive day - thank the Lord that when I get my full passport I will have 10 years before going through all of this again - SA passports cannot be renewed - you have to apply for a new one when it expires. Hope this helps someone.
  • edited 12:21PM
    I left SA in late 2008 on a UK Passport (holding dual nationality but no SA Passport). As I have just got my UK Passport, it was queried at Passport Control. I advised that I only had 1 passport and would apply for my SA Passport in the UK (they also viewed my SA ID Book). I've never been able to get hold of the SA Embassy (phone numbers and email addresses dont seem to work). I got back to SA each year for just under 3 weeks getting my 90 day visitor permit. I have thought of applying for my SA Passport in SA (through SA Home Affairs) but am not sure how long it takes and if I have to collect it from Home Affairs or if I can have it posted to my SA address (where my parents reside). Otherwise how long would they hold onto it as I could collect it a year later.
  • edited 12:21PM

    I've read with interest all your posts. I was born in SA to SA parents and came to the UK in 1983 after marring a man who was born in Scotland and therefore was a UK citizen. At one point I had both UK and SA passports and used both as per previous posts. The only thing was that when I came back to the UK it was queried as to how I got into SA if there was no stamp on my UK passport and I was told I wasn't allowed to use both passports at the same time. My SA passport expired many many years ago and I have been using my UK passport each time I visited SA and so far no-one has queried it. I was not aware of having to get permission before becomming a British Citizen (which was in 1986). I still have my old ID book but have since changed my surname and haven't yet update it. I would like to do this but after reading the above posts I'm beginning to think it may be more hassel than it's worth. I realy don't know if I still have dual nationality and would be grateful if someone could clear that up for me.
  • edited 12:21PM
    Hi! I'm confused need help. I was born in S.A. came to work to U.K. as a nurse in 2001. I leave with my daughter and we both retained naturalization and british citizen. My big problem is my S.A. passport expired on march 2011 and I went to London for renewal. When they check my documents I was told that I didn't return the letter with payment for retention of my SA citizen. I lost my S.A. citizen and they took my S.A. passport and ID stamped cancelled. Iwas given a letter Acquisition of British Citizeship to produce at passport control with british passport when visit S.A.I received a letter from S.A. High Commission stated Loss of South African Citizenship to inform me that my non-citizen status has been recorded by S.A. home Affairs. I may apply for new identity doc.given new ID number. I dont know whether to go aheard or wait until I visit in Feb 2012. I am worried about my bank delails and in case they do some changes. Can anybody give me advise.
  • edited 12:21PM
    Hi All - has anyone used The Pienaar Group to renew their South African passport mentioned earlier in this string in 2011. Thanks.
  • edited 12:21PM
    Defo apply for retention as you will be given a new ID number which is a new number to remember! I have had some experiance with this as I lost my SA citizenship but then retained it again. I was born in California to A South African father and British mother. We moved ack to SA when I was 2 and I studied and lived there all my adolecent life. I then, after Uni, went to the UK and applied to UK citizenship on the back of my Moms status and did a Post Grad study there. I then applied for a US citizenship (this is automatic if you where born in the US) So now I hold 3 citizenships. I allways maintained my SA passport but when we decided to go back to SA to live, I found out I had lost my citizenship but could apply for resumption which I did. Becasue I did this in time I kept my ID number but have to leave SA on my SA passport and then depending on where I am going I use either UK or USA passport.
  • edited 12:21PM
    Hi all,
    My father is South African and mother a from Tanzania. I now want to relocate to South Africa and get citizenship of my father (South African) but the people at Home Affairs are givin me a hard time asking why I want South African citizenship. What must I tell them to convince them
  • edited 12:21PM
    I am a South African citizen. My father was born in London in 1932 at some stage during his childhood years he and his mother moved to SA. Since my father was born in the UK do i then qualify for citizenship? I am in the process of submitting my application for citizenship to the Local British Consulate offices but after doing some research I'm now thoroughly confused by whether or not i have entitlement to citizenship or not. My father died a number of years ago so I don't know what his circumstances were. I urgently want to relocate to the UK and since I'm over 30 have no idea what other options i have to do so.
Sign In or Register to comment.